A crazy trade rumor from Toronto sends Sidney Crosby to Montreal

EDITOR'S NOTE: This is a translated article originally published to Habsolumentfan.com by staff writer Marco Normandin.

Sidney Crosby 's future continues to be a hot topic throughout the NHL. With the summer of 2026 approaching and the Pittsburgh Penguins captain still not having entered into formal contract extension negotiations, speculation is rife. And some of the proposals made publicly are enough to raise eyebrows among fans, both in Pittsburgh and Montreal.

A contract that is eagerly awaited in Pittsburgh

According to reports from Josh Yohe of The Athletic , Crosby's agent, Pat Brisson , confirmed that discussions regarding a potential contract extension have not yet begun. Brisson did, however, specify that there is a tacit agreement between the two parties to address the matter before the end of the summer.

Crosby has previously expressed his desire to finish his career in Pittsburgh, signing one- or two-year deals. Last summer, rumors circulated about a possible departure for number 87, but this year, nothing of the sort seems to be on the horizon for the Pennsylvania franchise. The atmosphere appears calm, even if the lack of concrete discussions in mid-August might raise some questions among Penguins fans.

A controversial proposal involving the Montreal Canadiens

It was in this context of contractual uncertainty that radio host Sid Seixeiro , at the helm of his daily show, floated an idea that quickly sparked a reaction. Speaking live from Toronto, Seixeiro suggested that the Montreal Canadiens should try to acquire Sidney Crosby , and even submitted an offer that he believed would be sufficient to complete a trade with the Penguins.

IN MONTREAL: Sidney Crosby

TO PITTSBURGH: Michael Hage + 2027 1st round pick

Following this offer, Seixero wondered: "Who in Montreal would refuse this trade? Nobody!"

The reaction from hockey fans was swift and overwhelmingly negative. Many Canadiens supporters deemed the proposal completely disproportionate, believing it would be foolish to sacrifice a promising player like Hage for a veteran nearing the end of his career, however legendary he may be. Comments ranged from a simple, categorical "no" to more elaborate criticisms questioning the very logic of such a trade. One user pointed out that including Hage in such a transaction simply made no sense.

Conversely, many admit that bringing Crosby into the Canadiens' locker room would have positive repercussions for the next 25 years on the franchise as well as on all the young players he would be around.

The next few weeks will be crucial for Crosby's future. If the talks with Pittsburgh conclude as expected before the end of the summer, this saga should be over quickly. Otherwise, the wildest rumors will undoubtedly continue to fuel discussions throughout the league.