
The Sabres aren't planning to use that fourth overall pick the way you'd expect.
The 2026 NHL Draft opens tonight in Buffalo, and the host team finds itself at the epicenter of the trade rumor universe. But the biggest storyline isn't about who the Sabres plan to select. It's about the massive deal they're reportedly trying to pull off before any names are called.
Buffalo sent defenseman Bowen Byram and forward Jordan Greenway to the Chicago Blackhawks earlier this week, bringing back a haul headlined by the fourth overall pick. It was a bold move on its own, but it now appears to be just the opening act.
According to insider David Pagnotta, the Sabres have no intention of using that fourth pick to draft a prospect. Instead, they want to package it as the centerpiece of a trade for an established, impact player.
The target, according to multiple reports, could very well be Toronto Maple Leafs power forward Matthew Knies.
Knies, 23, put up 66 points in 79 games last season and has cemented himself as a legitimate top-six winger with size, skill, and a rapidly improving two-way game. He's young, ascending, and still under team control, making him exactly the type of player a franchise pushing toward contention would chase.
The fit makes even more sense given that Buffalo also moved Alex Tuch to Washington in a separate deal. Knies would reportedly serve as a younger, more cost-effective replacement who could immediately elevate the Sabres' forward group.
The hurdle is Toronto's asking price. Leafs GM John Chayka has reportedly set the bar extremely high, seeking at minimum a top-10 draft pick, a legitimate number-one defenseman, and a secondary roster piece in any deal involving Knies. Some rival executives have reportedly questioned whether Toronto is genuinely open to moving him or simply testing the market.
Still, the fourth overall pick changes the calculus significantly. A top-five selection is the kind of asset that could anchor a package even the most demanding seller would struggle to turn down. This year's draft class is stacked with elite defensive prospects like Carson Carels, Chase Reid, and Keaton Verhoeff, giving Toronto plenty of reason to be intrigued, especially since the Leafs already hold the first overall pick where consensus top prospect Gavin McKenna is expected to land.
Buffalo now holds both the fourth and 20th overall selections, giving the front office serious firepower to bundle together in negotiations. The Sabres made the playoffs this past season after years of futility, and the front office is clearly determined to build on that momentum rather than take a patient, draft-and-develop approach.
Trading a potential future star for a proven one is always a gamble. But for a team that finally tasted postseason hockey and wants more, it's the kind of calculated risk that could define their trajectory.
For now, all eyes will be on Buffalo's draft table tonight. If the Sabres can meet Toronto's steep demands, the fourth overall pick may never actually be used to call a prospect's name.
Get the latest news and updates directly in your inbox.
About the author
Writer
Christine has been a lifelong hockey fan ever since she fell for Mario Lemieux’ slick moves and Jaromir Jagr’s mullet. A professional writer, she joined Attraction Media in 2017. Since then, she has good reasons to watch all hockey games and can humiliate several men who can’t handle that a woman knows more about hockey than they ever will.
Read more